How AI Search Recommends Local Businesses

AI search, the “answer-first” experience delivered by models like ChatGPT (when connected to the web), Perplexity, and Google’s Gemini-powered Search Generative Experience, has changed how people discover local businesses. Instead of a list of links, users often get direct recommendations, shortlists, or AI summaries that pull from multiple sources. That shift means the signals that make a business show up and be trusted are changing too.

Below I explain how these AI systems find and recommend local businesses, the differences between major players, the practical signals you should optimize, limitations and risks, and an actionable checklist + prompt templates you can use today.

TL;DR

• AI search systems synthesize answers from multiple sources (business listings, reviews, websites, directories, news). Being present and consistent across those sources is critical.

• Google’s AI (Gemini / Search Generative Experience) leans heavily on Google Business Profile data + reviews + structured data; Perplexity emphasizes high-quality, citable sources; ChatGPT’s recommendations depend on whether it’s using live web integrations (Bing / plugins) versus only training data.

• Top practical priorities: complete & accurate Google Business Profile, lots of fresh positive reviews, consistent NAP/citations across directories, clear local content (service + city pages), schema markup, and third-party mentions.

• Be aware of limits: hallucinations, stale training data, and legal/content-blocking friction between publishers and AI indexers (affects source coverage).

1) How AI search finds businesses

1. Index / data sources: AI search systems pull from a set of sources: Google Business Profile (GBP)/Maps data, directories (Yelp, Foursquare), review sites, the business’s website (structured data + content), news articles, and sometimes proprietary publisher feeds and partnerships. The exact mix differs by product.

2. Retrieval / evidence scoring: The system retrieves candidate documents/records and ranks them by trustworthiness signals (authority of source, recency, corroboration across sources). Perplexity, for example, emphasizes surfaced citations; Google uses its maps/ranking signals plus generative summarization; ChatGPT’s answers can come from its training or live web integrations when available.

3. Synthesis / summarization: The model synthesizes an answer (shortlist, explanation, “best X near you”) and often includes citations or links (the platforms vary in citation practice). AI systems prefer to surface businesses backed by multiple corroborating sources and strong reputation signals.

4. User signals / personalization: Location, query phrasing (intent), and personalization (past behavior, language) strongly shape which businesses are returned. For local queries, proximity + relevance + prominence remain key.

2) Differences between ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google / Gemini

Google (Gemini / SGE / AI Overviews)

Deeply integrated with Google’s Maps, GBP, and its index; it can produce “AI Overviews” for local queries that highlight reviews, services, hours, and action buttons. GBP completeness and reviews are high-weight signals.

Perplexity

Markets itself as an “answer engine” prioritizing explicit citations and high-quality web sources. Perplexity emphasizes trustworthiness and often surfaces the publisher sources in the answer. It’s also rapidly partnering to localize models and expand source coverage.

ChatGPT (OpenAI models with/without browsing)

Out of the box (no live web), ChatGPT uses training data (which can be stale). With web plugins/browsing or integrations (e.g., ChatGPT Search powered by Bing), it can return live, sourced local recommendations — but coverage and source selection depend on the integration and prompt. ChatGPT has had accuracy issues on local business facts in the past, so it may hallucinate unless prompted to verify.

Why it matters for businesses: each product values slightly different signals (GBP + reviews vs. high-quality published sources vs. site content + structured data). Optimizing broadly across all signals is the safest strategy.

3) What these systems really look for

The exact weights change across platforms, but across studies and industry observations the following signals repeatedly show up as decisive.

1. Google Business Profile (GBP) completeness & categories: accurate hours, services, photos, descriptions, service areas. (Critical for Google/Gemini).

2. Reviews: quantity, recency, sentiment, and review response. AI systems surface and quote reviews as evidence. More high-quality recent reviews help.

3. Consistent NAP and directory citations: consistent listings across high-authority directories (Yelp, Foursquare, industry directories) build corroboration. BrightLocal and others show directories still matter in AI discovery.

4. On-site local content & intent matching: service + city pages, clear FAQs, local schema (LocalBusiness, Service schema). Semantic clarity helps AI models match intent.

5. Authoritative third-party mentions: news, local press, high-authority blog features; AI favors citable sources. Perplexity and similar services particularly prize authoritative external mentions.

6. Technical accessibility / crawlability: structured data (schema.org), fast site, good mobile UX — makes it easier for crawlers and evidence extractors to find and parse your info.

4) Practical, actionable checklist

Immediate (0–2 weeks)

• Claim and fully complete your Google Business Profile: categories, description, services, business hours, photos, menu/price (if relevant), booking link. Keep it accurate.

• Audit your NAP consistency across top directories (Yelp, Bing Places, Foursquare, industry directories). Fix mismatches.

• Start a review generation program: ask customers (SMS/email/receipts) for honest reviews; respond to each review professionally. Fresh positive reviews are high value for AI overviews.

Short term (2–8 weeks)

• Add structured data (JSON-LD) for LocalBusiness, Service, and Review on relevant pages. Validate with rich results tools.

• Create or improve dedicated local landing pages (service + city) with clear, specific, local terms and FAQs that answer common local queries (e.g., “plumber in Chesapeake — emergency hot water repair”).

• Build at least 5–10 authoritative citations/mentions (local news, industry directories, community sites).

Ongoing (month → year)

• Keep generating reviews, maintain GBP posts (offers/events), and publish local content/Case Studies. Monitor AI-driven SERP changes and what sources are being cited for your key queries.

5) Prompt templates

If you want an AI to use live sources and avoid hallucination, instruct it explicitly:

For users (searchers): “Recommend 3 open family-friendly Italian restaurants within 5 miles of [CITY, ZIP]. Only include restaurants with 4.0+ average on Google or Yelp and fewer than 15 minutes drive from [ADDRESS]. Cite the source for each recommendation.”

For business owners (testing presence): “Search the web and list the top 3 sources that mention [Business Name] in [City]. Include the URL, publication date, and whether the listing has NAP details. Use only live web sources and cite them.”

For SEOs (audit prompt): “Give me the top 10 signals that would make [service] visible in AI-generated local answers in 2025, and list 5 gaps on [domain] that hurt discoverability. Use live sources to justify each signal.”

Prompting systems to cite and verify reduces hallucination and forces the model to prefer evidence-backed choices.

Need a Quick Web Design Checkup?

We offer FREE Website & SEO Audits for local businesses in Virginia Beach, Chesapeake, Hampton Roads, and beyond.

Danielle Leland

Author, Owner

With a BSBA and 3 years of design experience, Danielle is a Hampton Roads based web design, SEO, & brand designer helping service businesses grow online.

6) Limitations, risks, and the legal landscape

Hallucinations and stale data: models without live web access can invent businesses or outdated details. Always verify facts with direct sources (GBP, site).

Publisher / copyright friction: publishers (e.g., NYT) have pushed back on some AI indexing practices; this affects which sources are available to AI and can change which businesses get surfaced. Expect source coverage to keep shifting as legal agreements are negotiated.

Bias & personalization: AI recommendations reflect training data and the sources the product prioritizes; that can skew results toward more ‘visible’ businesses (big brands, those with many citations).

7) Quick case examples (what to do in specific industries)

Home services (plumbers, HVAC, roofing): emphasize GBP category accuracy, service area settings, service-specific pages (“emergency AC repair in [City]”), and abundant local reviews. AI overviews for these queries often cite reviews and GBP info.

Restaurants: menus in GBP + structured menu schema, up-to-date hours, photos, and strong review management. AI restaurant recommendations commonly quote review sentiment.

Medical / legal: authoritative third-party citations (local press, directories like Healthgrades or Avvo) and clear licensing info are critical because AI and users expect credentials and trust signals.

8) Measurement: how to know it’s working

Track mentions: set alerts for your business name + city and log which sites AI platforms cite for target queries.

Monitor traffic changes to local landing pages and GBP insights (queries, discovery searches, calls).

Periodically run the same prompts across ChatGPT (with web), Perplexity, and Google search (AI Mode/Gemini) and record which businesses are cited and why. Use those findings to fill gaps (missing directories, lack of reviews, etc.).

9) What’s coming next (trends to watch)

AI Overviews & Google AI Mode will grow: GBP and reviews will be even more critical as Google surfaces direct hiring/buying recommendations.

Perplexity and niche answer engines: firms are partnering with publishers and localizing models (e.g., Nvidia + Perplexity) to provide regionally accurate results, good news if you serve multilingual or non-US markets.

Greater emphasis on citable evidence: platforms that visibly cite sources will reward businesses with strong third-party coverage.

10) Action plan you can implement this week

1. Claim/verify Google Business Profile (if not done). Add photos and 3 service descriptions. (Day 1)

2. Run a NAP audit across top 10 directories; fix inconsistencies. (Days 1–3)

3. Ask 10 recent customers for Google/Yelp reviews and respond to existing reviews. (Week 1)

4. Add JSON-LD LocalBusiness schema to your homepage and service pages; validate. (Week 1–2)

5. Test target queries on Google (AI Mode), Perplexity, and ChatGPT with the prompt templates above; record sources and gaps. (Ongoing)

Key sources and further reading

BrightLocal: “AI Search Makes Local Listings More Important Than Ever.”

Direction / Local SEO guides: comprehensive local ranking factor reviews for 2025.

Perplexity docs / guides on queries and enterprise features.

Reuters: Perplexity & Nvidia partnership for localized AI models (shows industry direction).

The Verge / news on publisher pushback against AI indexing (legal limits on source coverage).

Contact us today for a free consultation.

Want your business to show up when customers search?

Our local SEO services help Hampton Roads contractors, plumbers, and service pros rank higher and get more calls.

Recent Design Insights & Trends

10 Website Mistakes That Are Killing Your Conversions

The Ultimate Guide to Building a Free Website

Why Your Website Isn’t Getting Leads

Ready to Grow Your Business Online?

Let's figure out exactly what your business needs to bring in leads.